Corporate Assessment for ongoing Directors
Corporate Due Diligence-Finance, Strategic Direction & Governance
FINANCE
- What financial issues exist for this company?
STRATEGIC DIRECTION
- What is the apparent problem with the board’s current role in the development and management strategy at this company?
- What does Behan Legal recommend the board should do about this problem?
GOVERNANCE
- What problems exist in the composition of the board?
- What does Behan Legal recommend on how to address these problems?
In assessing corporate competence and responsibility, Behan Legal analyses the components before looking or digging for data and information that will form the basis of its Corporate Assessment. It does not give accounting advice; however, clients can choose suitable accountants from the Behan Legal panel.
NEED MORE INFORMATION
Behan Legal assists and advises on these important issues only in conference. For an appointment, call 03 9646 0344.
Performance Indicators |
|||||
Years |
|
|
|
|
Return on Assets (ROA) |
|
|
|
|
Profitability Performance Indicators |
||||||
EBIT |
||||||
EBIT Margin |
||||||
Gross Margin |
||||||
Total Operating Expense Margin |
||||||
Wages Margin |
||||||
Rent Margin |
||||||
Asset Performance Indicators |
|||||
Asset Turnover |
|||||
Inventory Turnover (in days) |
|||||
Debtors’ Turnover (in days) |
Debt Performance Indicators |
|||||
Total Liabilities to Total Assets |
|||||
Total Interest-Bearing Debt to Total Assets |
|||||
Interest Cover |
Performance Indicators |
Formula |
Comments/Explanations |
Issues |
ROA (Return on Assets) |
Ebit Total sales |
EBIT is net profit (not earnings) before interest & tax TOTAL ASSETS is all current assets, fixed assets & intangible assets |
If ROA is low, look at profitability, asset & debt performance How do we increase profit relative to sales? (EBIT/SALES) Reduce expenses, become productive Maintain expenses & increase sales by increasing price Maintain expenses & price but sell more How do we improve asset performance? (SALES/TOTAL ASSETS) Improve profitability management Maintain sales Improve asset management- reduce total amount of assets necessary to make sales |
Profitability Performance Indicators |
Formula |
Issues |
EBIT Margin |
EBIT SALES |
This margin shows by percentage every cent made in every sales dollar before interest & tax. Problem areas, include: Reduced gross margins (reduced profit on buying & selling stock) Increased expenses Insufficient staffing structures Insufficient sales not covering expenses |
Gross Margin |
GROSS PROFIT SALES |
Monitors management & staff ability to profitably buy & sell stock at profit, manufacture & sell stock at a profit, or provide & sell a service at a profit If the company does not make sufficient profit at this level it cannot earn money elsewhere. To improve, one must: Buy / negotiate at stock lower prices Increase selling price Reduce manufacturing costs |
Total operating expense margin |
TOTAL OPERATING EXPENSE-INTEREST SALES |
Critical to monitor operating expenses (not interest) such as wages, rent & depreciation as a percentage of sales on a regular basis. Investigate any increase as it affects Gross Margin. If it steadily increases, then: Calculate specific operating expenses as a percentage of sales Identify operating expenses that are increasing over time Make recommendations to improve performance For example, Wages Margin, Rent Margin etc, will help monitor expenses and the rate of change over time. |
Wages Margin |
WAGES SALES |
|
Rent Margin |
RENT SALES |
Asset Performance Indicators |
Formula |
Issues |
Asset Turnover |
SALES TOTAL ASSETS |
This ratio measures the dollar amount sales generated by the company’s investment in assets. Compare the level of asset turnover with industry averages before reaching a reliable assessment of asset performance. This turnover is concerned with the balance sheet and concerns itself with how they are used as a productive resource, i.e., the level of sales generated by total assets under the control of people. Asset Performance can be improved by: Reducing level of investment in non-current assets Reducing stock levels relative to sales Reducing debtors relative to sales |
Asset Performance Indicators |
Formula |
Issues |
Inventory Turnover (in days) |
Cost of goods sold stock = x (times) 365 days x (times) =Y (days) |
This turnover ratio monitors the ability to buy and sell stock as many times a year as possible, or the time the stock remains in the store before it is sold. Compare the level of asset turnover with industry averages before reaching a reliable assessment of asset performance. But, if the rate increases over time: Calculate rate of turnover Compare with industry standards & identify if acceptable or not Make specific recommendations such as reviewing: Buying procedures Stock re-order procedures Obsolete stock Individual product categories Stock re-order quantities Sales relative to stock levels for specific product lines |
Asset Performance Indicators |
Formula |
Issues |
Debtors’ Turnover (in days) |
Sales revenue (account not cash sales) debtors = x (times) 365 days x (times) = y (days) |
This turnover rate monitors the ability to collect outstanding debts and the time debtors take to pay. Compare the level of asset turnover with industry averages before reaching a reliable assessment of asset performance. But, if the debtors increase over time: Calculate rate of turnover Compare with industry standards & identify if acceptable or not Make specific recommendations such as reviewing: Debt collection procedures Account sale procedures Bad debtors Ageing of debtors Invoice & statement procedures Sales relative to specific debtors |
Debt Performance Indicators |
Formula |
Issues |
Total Liabilities to Total Assets |
Total liabilities Total assets |
This rate monitors if shareholders’ equity is increasing or being affected by increasing debt performance. Good levels of EBIT may be lost by high rates of interest on borrowed money. To improve debt performance: Maintain level of assets & reduce debt Reduce interest paid The rate shows for every $1 invested in assets how much has been borrowed (in percentage) and the amount provided by shareholders in the form of equity. Ideally total liabilities should be 30-50% of total assets and anything higher requires immediate action. Debt Performance concerns itself with profit & loss statements and balance sheet, not with assets but with liabilities, which cannot generate a profit. Shareholders need good EBIT and only get what is left after interest bearing debt and tax. Poor debt management reduces EBIT and final return to shareholders |
Total Interest Bearing Debt to Total Assets |
Total interest bearing debt Assets = x% |
This rate monitors if there is an increase in interest-bearing debt as a percentage of total assets. It shows the amount of assets being used to finance the interest-bearing debt and what is actually available for tax and dividends. For example, the assets are earning ROA and X% of these assets has been financed at Y% pa. Y% pa is calculated by dividing the interest paid by the total interest bearing debt expressed as a percentage, or Y%/ROA x X%= Z% EBIT on Z% of the assets are being used to finance the interest bearing debt. If the rate is increasing: Refinance or reduce interest rates Improve EBIT as percentage of total assets Reduce inventories, debtors and use cash to repay interest bearing debt Sell unproductive assets and use cash to repay interest bearing debt Sell productive assets and use cash to repay interest bearing debt |
Interest Cover |
Ebit Interest paid = X (times) |
This rate monitors the capacity to repay interest on all interest-bearing debt. It shows how much $X in profit for every $1 in interest that has to be paid from that $X profit. It is an aim for an interest cover of at least 5 times. |
Debt Performance Indicators |
Formula |
Issues |
Total Liabilities to Total Assets |
Total liabilities Total assets |
This rate monitors if shareholders’ equity is increasing or being affected by increasing debt performance. Good levels of EBIT may be lost by high rates of interest on borrowed money. To improve debt performance: Maintain level of assets & reduce debt Reduce interest paid The rate shows for every $1 invested in assets how much has been borrowed (in percentage) and the amount provided by shareholders in the form of equity. Ideally total liabilities should be 30-50% of total assets and anything higher requires immediate action. Debt Performance concerns itself with profit & loss statements and balance sheet, not with assets but with liabilities, which cannot generate a profit. Shareholders need good EBIT and only get what is left after interest bearing debt and tax. Poor debt management reduces EBIT and final return to shareholders |
Total Interest Bearing Debt to Total Assets |
Total interest bearing debt Assets = x% |
This rate monitors if there is an increase in interest-bearing debt as a percentage of total assets. It shows the amount of assets being used to finance the interest-bearing debt and what is actually available for tax and dividends. For example, the assets are earning ROA and X% of these assets has been financed at Y% pa. Y% pa is calculated by dividing the interest paid by the total interest bearing debt expressed as a percentage, or Y%/ROA x X%= Z% EBIT on Z% of the assets are being used to finance the interest bearing debt. If the rate is increasing: Refinance or reduce interest rates Improve EBIT as percentage of total assets Reduce inventories, debtors and use cash to repay interest bearing debt Sell unproductive assets and use cash to repay interest bearing debt Sell productive assets and use cash to repay interest bearing debt |
Interest Cover |
Ebit Interest paid = X (times) |
This rate monitors the capacity to repay interest on all interest-bearing debt. It shows how much $X in profit for every $1 in interest that has to be paid from that $X profit. It is an aim for an interest cover of at least 5 times. |